00:00 - 00:03Fall tour was great, but as usual
00:04 - 00:05it all led up to NYE at MSG
00:05 - 00:07in NYC, the center of the universe
00:08 - 00:1212-28 is a throwaway. No one is relistening.
00:12 - 00:15But what went down on 12-29 is nuts.
00:17 - 00:19This is that crazy set one closer?
00:19 - 00:21I've heard it. Totally wild.
00:24 - 00:26Charlie, some people think
00:27 - 00:28that Party Time should be on the set list
00:31 - 00:33By people, we mean, like, everybody.
00:34 - 00:36Including Tom Marshall. And the band's Twitter.
00:53 - 00:58If you're a 3.0 noob, gtfo.
01:13 - 01:15If Fishman took a shit with cymbals
01:15 - 01:17is that Party Time? Fuck no!
01:18 - 01:23Are there rules?
01:25 - 01:28Or is this set list anarchy?
01:29 - 01:31They didn't play the drum part ffs!!
01:31 - 01:34I will not budge on this! Never!
01:34 - 01:37It's not a performance, just a quote!
01:37 - 01:40Listen to the other versions and get back to me!
01:40 - 01:42They sang it several times, come on, dude.
01:42 - 01:46Sang the words! Just the words!
01:46 - 01:48Let's just give the public what they want
01:48 - 01:52So now set lists are drafted by mob rule?
01:53 - 01:54I've been at this too long
01:56 - 01:57I can't have 3.0 noobs steering this ship
01:57 - 02:00next thing you know, there are 25 DEG teases per show
02:00 - 02:03when it's usually just
02:04 - 02:08a Trey trill that barely sounds like DEG
02:08 - 02:13and I will not tolerate that
02:14 - 02:16it’s objectively true that the Phish song “Party Time” was not performed on 12-29
02:17 - 02:21It doesn’t matter what you or I believe.
02:27 - 02:29I can't even bask in the joy of the 12-30 Bliss because of this shit
02:30 - 02:34Or the Glide II.
02:34 - 02:36I've been waiting for that since 1995
02:41 - 02:42The composed sections of Party Time weren’t performed
02:43 - 02:47except arguably one or two chords by Page shortly before the end of the jam.
02:48 - 02:53The SONG was not performed/played
02:54 - 02:56the formal setlist will be misleading to some no matter what we do
02:56 - 02:59The music of the song was literally not performed, so there’s that
03:00 - 03:02But because its ONLY lyric (100%) was repeated for many measures over a jam, there’s that.
03:04 - 03:07More ladies at the show today than normal, huh?
03:14 - 03:16I'll tell you what
03:19 - 03:23Consensus seems to be to note “Party Time” in the setlist formally
03:25 - 03:26even if its music technically wasn’t performed
03:31 - 03:33This is a sad day for phish.net
03:40 - 03:46And me personally
03:46 - 03:49I've been at this since 1989
03:53 - 03:56But you win. Add Party Time to the set list.